For English class, we were supposed to have read three short stories (of which I read one): Harrison Bergeron, Those Who Walk Away from Omelas, and The Lottery. I read Harrison Bergeron, and I absolutely loved it. It was terribly sad, but it was so beautiful and an amazing show of how noble the battle of the individual against the collective is.
Basically, in this dystopian futuristic society, the Constitution has been ammended 218 times, and men are “finally equal”. There is a branch of government in charge of this, and how they make everyone equal is by “handicapping” those that are exceptional. Intelligent men are made to wear earpieces that blast loud noises into their heads every once in a while in order to interrupt their trains of thought, strong people are forced to wear huge weights all the time to weigh them down, and beautiful people are forced to wear incredibly ugly masks.
The story starts with Hazel and George, a married couple who have just had their son Harrison taken from them and thrown in jail, watching TV; there is a ballet on. The dancers occasionally fall to the ground from the noises in their earpieces, and they all have ugly masks to hide their beauty. The program is interrupted by a stuttering newscaster to announce an important news bulletin, but he has a stutter and cannot convey the message, so he hands the broadcast to a ballerina to read. She has an especially ugly mask, which is understood by Hazel, an average, un-handicapped woman, to mean that she is exceptionally beautiful. The ballerina appologizes for her beautiful voice, and changes it in order to deliver her broadcast: Harrison has escaped jail and he is to be ignored at all costs by the people. At that moment, the set begins to rumble. Everyone falls over, and Harrison rushes onto the screen—He is tall, exactly seven feet, and he is covered in handicaps. His teeth were too straight and white, so he wears black caps over some of them. He is covered in 300 lbs of weights. His eyebrows have been shaved off. He wears a red rubber nose. He wears huge, thick-lensed glasses.
Harrison reaches out to the people. He claims to be their emperor. He then commands all to look at him as he reaches his full potential beauty— He removes all of his handicaps, becoming the man he is supposed to be. He then announces that the first of the ballerinas to stand with him shall be his empress—and alas, one stands. He removes her mask, and she is beautiful. He picks up a few of the musicians, and commands them to play in the way that they know is beautiful, not in the disgusting handicapped way that they have previously been forced to play in. The musicians listen to him, and he and his emperess begin to dance. They are described as leaping so high that they kiss the thirty foot ceiling. The scene described here is beautiful— and as they kiss eachother in mid air, the officer in charge of handicapping bursts through the door with a giant gun and kills Harrison and his empress before they hit the ground. She commands the musicians to replace their handicaps and forces things to return to the way they were.
Harrison’s parents cry for him. George’s earpiece knocks him to the floor, and Hazel cares for him, with tears still running down her face, even though she has forgotten what she has just seen. George has also lost the memory of his son’s tragic public death.
Harrison Bergeron is a tragic story, yes. But it delivers a powerful message about the individual versus the collective, and how ridiculous it is to keep ammending our Constitution until it is no longer the same document and until it forces men to abandon all rights to their individuality, and only worry about being noticed as exceptional at anything, because that means certain suffering.
My english professor tried to convince our class that this story is one of condemning technology, and promoting socialism. How, I do not understand, because I do not see that connection anywhere. He also described it as a comedy. I see nothing funny in that story. I see nothing to smile about besides Harrison’s courage and beauty, which is brutally annihilated in the end. I see no reason for my professor to come to this conclusion. It is ridiculous and farfetched since the theme of the story is so obvious. I am thoroughly stumped by the lack of reason displayed at my school today. I am finding it hard to concentrate on anything else… Because if people are so willing to accept this fictional society as funny, how far away are we from becoming like it?